
Fittingly, it has come to this. Always did seem as though Donovan McNabb was destined to be jettisoned out of Philadelphia under a cloud of controversy - which he had no part in creating.
Eagles head coach Andy Reid announced on Jan. 11, his franchise quarterback would return for a twelfth season in Philly, seemingly squelching speculation about No. 5's future. Ten weeks later, McNabb's status for 2010 and beyond is anything but certain. Tune into ESPN and you won't have to wait long for the latest installment of Where in the World is Donovan Going. Sources throughout the Eagles' front office have consistently confirmed that the team is, in fact, entertaining trade offers for McNabb and seriously considering sending him packing.

Perhaps most telling is that Reid has stayed predominately mum on the escalating issue. Big Red has only gone as far to say that several other NFL organizations have inquired about each of his three passers - McNabb, Kevin Kolb and Michael Vick. Reid also stated that he could see the Eagles bringing back the entire trio for training camp - though that seems far-fetched. All three are entering the final year on their respective contracts but each are currently at very different stages in their professional football careers.
We all know Vick's story. The former Virginia Tech and Atlanta Falcons standout is still on the comeback trail after his kennel crimes and still has the ability to start for a handful of teams in the league. Kolb, who would likely take the reigns at starting QB if McNabb is dealt, is a 25-year-old with two career starts under his belt. When Philadelphia grabbed him at the top of the second round in the 2007 Draft, eyebrows were certainly raised. Despite being limited to ten games in 2006, McNabb compiled a sterling touchdown to interception ratio of 18 to six. However, production likely wasn't the determinant factor when Reid selected the former University of Houston star with the 36th overall pick. McNabb missed a total of 13 games between the 2005 and 2006 seasons and, despite being just 30 years old, there were questions about whether or not he could still make it through the grind of a full NFL season. So the Eagles went with the motto "better to be safe than sorry".
McNabb answered critics by throwing for a total of 64 touchdowns and just 28 interceptions in the three seasons since Kolb was drafted. However, over that span there have been several events that ultimately helped lead to his current state of limbo. There was the 2008 tie with Cincinnati, after which McNabb surprisingly admitted he was not aware that an NFL game could end in a stalemate. The following week at Baltimore - with the Eagles offense sputtering - Reid did the unthinkable. McNabb was told to take a seat for the first time in his career. Kolb was inserted at quarterback for the second half and proceeded to throw a game-deciding interception, which was promptly returned 108 yards by Ed Reed for a Ravens touchdown. The fallout from the McNabb benching shook the football world until Reid announced that he was still going with the veteran as his starter the following week - a nationally televised primetime Thanksgiving game in Philadelphia. McNabb responded by completing 27-of-39 passes for 260 yards, with four touchdowns and no interceptions in a 48-20 win over the Cardinals.
The Eagles traveled to Glendale, Ariz., to face the Cardinals again two months later - with a Super Bowl berth on the line. McNabb was at his finest leading Philadelphia during a memorable run to end the '08 campaign. Despite his up-and-down season, he helped the Eagles reach the playoffs for the seventh time in his nine seasons as a starter. He also set a career-high with 3,916 yards passing and led the Eagles to a franchise-record 416 points. Philly was considered by many to be the hottest team in the NFL when the playoffs rolled around. They confirmed those sentiments by knocking off both the Minnesota Vikings and the rival New York Giants on the road.

But when McNabb emerged from the tunnel for the second half of the game in Glendale with his team trailing the Cardinals 24-6, it looked as though he would surely pick up the fourth NFC Championship loss of his career. The Eagles had thirty minutes of football left to reverse their fortunes and earn a second Super Bowl appearance in four years. Rumors were swirling that Philadelphia would undergo major changes in the offseason to follow. The futures of fanchise stalwarts John Runyan, Tra Thomas and Brian Dawkins were in doubt - even Reid and McNabb appeared to lack complete job security for the first time.
Carrying the weight of the franchise's past failures on his shoulders, McNabb played arguably his best half of football as a professional quarterback. By the conclusion of the game, he would throw for 375 yards, with all three of his touchdowns coming in the second half. The last score - a 62-yard bomb to rookie DeSean Jackson - put the Eagles in front 25-24 with under eleven minutes remaining in the contest. The play would have become an iconic image of McNabb's greatest playoff moment to date but...

Kurt Warner and the Cardinals' offense answered by putting together a 14-play, 72-yard drive that took nearly eight minutes off the clock and resulted in 8 points. Down 32-25, Philadelphia got the ball back with under three minutes to play. The Eagles reached Cardinals' territory but could not find the end zone. Arizona advanced to the Super Bowl, while McNabb and Co. were left on the doorstep for the fourth time in seven years.
The Eagles defense coughed up a back-breaking, game-winning drive to Arizona when it needed a stop the most. Yet, for some reason the game will always be chalked up as yet another big one that McNabb let slip away. The inescapable negative energy surrounding Donovan in Philadelphia has always been present - even during his five pro bowl years. He has secured just about every franchise passing record, been an upstanding citizen off the field and is one of the premier winners of his era. Yet, here is McNabb now - his services being linked to a new team each day. If there's any truth to the possibility of him going to the Oakland Raiders - who are not likely to extend his contract - then it's unfortunate. McNabb deserves better and, if his future is not in Philly, he has earned the right to land with a respectable franchise that does things the right way.
Make no mistake about it - at 33 years old, McNabb is still one of the NFL's top 10 quarterbacks right now. His stats are favorable to those of Hall-of-Famer John Elway when examining the first eleven years of their respective careers:
McNabb: 32,873 yards / 216 touchdowns / 100 interceptions /
8 years with 80+ rating / 4 years with completion percentage over 60% /
6 pro bowls / 3,249 rushing yards
Elway: 34,516 yards / 183 touchdowns / 167 interceptions /
2 years with 80+ rating / 1 year with completion percentage over 60% /
5 pro bowls / 2,435 rushing yards
And Elway didn't own a Super Bowl ring until his 37th birthday.
So now it appears that McNabb will be playing elsewhere in 2010, ending a run with the organization that made him the second overall selection out of Syracuse in the 1999 Draft. He's the only franchise quarterback that Reid has ever had - they both arrived in Philly the same season. I was always under the impression that Reid would be gone first or that he and McNabb would both be shown the door together (this appeared on the horizon prior to the team's brilliant '08 stretch run). But now it looks as though the head coach is ready to say goodbye to his star pupil and begin shaping his next one in Kevin Kolb.

McNabb has always been a polarizing figure. He's been pegged as a terrific company man by some and a lap dog by others. Many love the way he's always smiling on the field - countless others despise it. Members of the media and the team's fan base often tried to pigeonhole him as an eratic-passing scrambler early in his career. That is until he developed into one of the league's best passers without having to leave the pocket - then they screamed he didn't run enough. His weapons have come and gone through the years, varying in their effectiveness. James Thrash was his No. 1 target for three seasons. Reid used his 2001 first-round pick to grab UCLA's Freddie Mitchell because he thought Fred Ex would be the perfect wide receiver for McNabb to grow old with. All-Pro receiver Terrell Owens arrived in Philly with fireworks, before swiftly exiting in the same fashion. Brian Westbrook was a loyal friend for many years, though injuries often limited his abilities. Duce Staley, LJ Smith, Todd Pinkston, Reggie Brown and Kevin Curtis all made cameos over the years.
Funny thing is, McNabb has never had the kind of supporting cast that would await him in Philly in 2010. The young trio of DeSean Jackson, Jeremy Maclin and Jason Avant lead the deepest receiving corp the Eagles have had since McNabb's arrival. Brent Celek performed like a Pro Bowler last season and is the best tight end to play in Reid's offense. Throw in a three-headed monster in the backfield - featuring LeSean McCoy, Mike Bell and Leonard Weaver - and you've got the makings of an extremely explosive offense.
On one hand, it makes sense for Philly to carry on with the youth movement, hand the keys to Kolb and give him a shot at leading the next generation of Eagles players. But I get the impression that the organization's decision-makers are talking themselves into trading their franchise player for the wrong reasons. Maybe it's an obligation of the front office to "stick to the plan" it established in '07 when the team added Kolb and McNabb's health was suspect. Or perhaps Reid has finally grown weary of answering all the questions about No. 5's future and is ready to move on. Whatever the case is, I have a very hard time convincing myself that the Eagles are better equipped for a run at a championship by dumping McNabb - and that's all that matters. Kolb is a great unknown. McNabb is as close to a sure thing that the NFL offers.

If this is the end of an era in The City of Brotherly Love, I'll look back on McNabb's years in Philly as one of the most successful franchise runs in recent league history. Over the past 20 years, only the Packers, 49ers, Colts and Patriots have enjoyed as consistent a decade as the Eagles. Unfortunately, five NFC Championship games equated to just one Super Bowl appearance - in which the Eagles narrowly lost to one of the NFL's all-time greatest teams.
People from outside Philadelphia have always wondered aloud how a city could at times be so brutal to its greatest sports star. Upon his arrival, McNabb immediately entered a hornet's nest due to Philly's football title drought - the Eagles have not won a championship since 1960. The team's excruciating flirtation with greatness during McNabb's tenure has only made fans more cynical. They've spent so much of the past eleven years expecting the worst that it has often cost them the ability to appreciate McNabb, the second greatest field general to direct the West Coast offense since Joe Montana - behind only Brett Favre and ahead of Steve Young.
Philadelphia still could have a change of heart, decide to reel the QB back in from the trading block and let him return to the only NFL home he's known. At this point though, why would he want to?








